Amazon.com Widgets

Pat Metheny w/ Dave Holland and Roy Haynes: Question and Answer (2008)

By Published: | 9,071 views
Pat Metheny w/ Dave Holland and Roy Haynes: Question and Answer How we rate: our writers tend to review music they like within their preferred genres.

Question and Answer is the second in a glittering, altogether too infrequent series of albums guitarist Pat Metheny has recorded in acoustic trio settings, usually on the hoof and with little post-production, which act as a counterweight to his more elaborate work with larger line-ups. Recorded in 1989 and originally released on Geffen, it's been immaculately remastered for this Nonesuch reissue.



The first of Metheny's trio albums was Rejoicing (ECM, 1983), with bassist Charlie Haden

Charlie Haden
Charlie Haden
1937 - 2014
bass, acoustic
and drummer Billy Higgins
Billy Higgins
Billy Higgins
1936 - 2001
drums
. The third and fourth were Trio 99-00 (Warner Bros, 1999), with bassist FLY
FLY
FLY

band/orchestra
and drummer Bill Stewart
Bill Stewart
Bill Stewart
b.1966
drums
, and Day Trip (Nonesuch, 2008), with bassist Christian McBride
Christian McBride
Christian McBride
b.1972
bass
and drummer Antonio Sanchez
Antonio Sanchez
Antonio Sanchez
b.1971
drums
.



If the established frequency is maintained, we can expect Metheny's fifth trio release round about 2017. Most jazz guitar fans would agree such a timeline amounts to cruel and unusual punishment in violation of the Eighth Amendment to the US Constitution. But Metheny presumably believes that his variegated discography—for something at the other end of the spectrum check out Upojenie (Nonesuch, 2008), a collaboration with the Polish singer Anna Maria Jopek, which has been reissued simultaneously with Question and Answer—permits no greater frequency.



Attempting to rate one of the trio albums as "the best" would be a meaningless exercise; such is the uniformly incandescent quality of the music involved. But anyone nominating Question and Answer would likely have in mind the contribution of drummer Roy Haynes

Roy Haynes
Roy Haynes
b.1926
drums
, which is supremely powerful magic—sensitive, sophisticated and responsive but also fat, mighty and propulsive. The sound of Haynes' kit is burnished to perfection on the remaster, and his performance fully justifies its inclusion alongside Metheny's at the front of the mix. Whether driving the band, counterpointing Metheny's solos or swopping quicksilver, viscerally thrilling choruses with him, Haynes is just heavenly.



A close to venerable 64 when the album was recorded, and still kicking 19 years later, Haynes' career is summarized on the 3-CD retrospective A Life In Time (Dreyfus, 2008).



Add bassist Dave Holland

Dave Holland
Dave Holland
b.1946
bass
, not as prominent as either Metheny or Haynes in the mix, but shining alongside them as soloist, and you have another magnificent Metheny trio line-up.



Recorded over a single day in December, 1989, the only track which deviates from the trio series' what-you-hear-is-what-you-get aesthetic is the closing "Three Flights Up," on which Metheny overdubbed Synclavier for a more layered sound. The pace is brisk going on jet-speed, with the exception of Metheny's "Never Too Far Away" and "Change Of Heart" (which won a Grammy Award for Best Instrumental Composition), both of which take a slower, more reflective route. There are five Metheny originals altogether, plus Miles Davis' "Solar" and Ornette Coleman's "Law Years," and two standards (Hill and Robinson's "Old Folks," taken at a sprightly step, and Kern and Hammerstein's "All The Things You Are," an elegant gallop).



A whirlwind of an affair, invigorating and exquisite; a masterpiece of the first order.

Track Listing: Solar; Question and Answer; H and H; Never Too Far Away; Law Years; Change of Heart; All The Things You Are; Old Folks; Three Flights Up.

Personnel: Pat Metheny: electric guitar, Sinclavier (9); Dave Holland: bass; Roy Haynes: drums.

Record Label: Nonesuch Records

Style: Modern Jazz


comments powered by Disqus
Search
Support All About Jazz Through Amazon

Weekly Giveaways

Mark Elf

Mark Elf

About | Enter

Stefano Bollani

Stefano Bollani

About | Enter

Carmen Lundy

Carmen Lundy

About | Enter

Wadada Leo Smith

Wadada Leo Smith

About | Enter

Bandzoogle: GET STARTED TODAY - FREE TRIAL

Enter it twice.
To the weekly jazz events calendar

Enter the numbers in the graphic
Enter the code in this picture

Log in

One moment, you will be redirected shortly.

Article Search