Opinion
Bomb Shelter Bebop
by John March
This may be the shortest article I've ever written for All About Jazz. It may also be one of the most important. It's about musicians, students, and teachers in Ukraine heading into another winter of war without reliable electricity, heat, or in some cases without even instruments, and what our community can do about it. I first met Mariana Bondarenko, head of music at the Ukrainian Institute, earlier this year at jazzahead! in Bremen. Since then, we've had ...
Continue Reading...Flamenco And Jazz Continue Along Different Paths Toward Institutional Recognition
by Francisco Julio Arenas Cabello
Nine decades have passed since the Spanish poet Federico García Lorca (Granada, 1898--Granada, August 18, 1936) was silenced. Yet his vision of duende--an expression of deep, dark emotion--and the blues, shaped both by Granada and Harlem, remains alive and in need of institutional protection. This exploration compares the explicit and robust cultural support given by Spain to flamenco with the more limited and fragmented institutional support afforded to jazz in the United States, particularly in New York City. It also ...
Continue Reading...Standards, Expertise and the Art of Judgment
by Patrick Keeney
American musician and musicologist Rick Beato recently criticised a list of the 30 greatest contemporary American songwriters compiled by music critics from The New York Times. He dismissed the exercise as meaningless. His objection was not primarily to compiling such a list, nor to the names nominated, but rather to the dubious authority of the critics themselves. Rick Beato is among the more knowledgeable commentators on contemporary music. He holds a Bachelor of Arts ...
Continue Reading...The Culture War - Springsteen, Brooks and The American People
by Thomas Cole
On January 30, 2026, the NY Times featured the final opinion column by David Brooks, and two days before I heard Bruce Springsteen's first (and probably not his final) protest" song. Somehow, they seem incontrovertibly linked in, to and with the history of this country. And to the very core of the human experience. Bruce Springsteen's song, apparently recorded in his home studio, unveils the soul of a pop star beyond his intermittent statements reported in the press. ...
Continue Reading...From The Heart To The Hips To The Head
by Robert J. Lewis
And those who were seen dancing were thought to be insane by those who could not hear the music. --Friedrich Nietzsche Without deviation from the norm, progress is not possible. --Frank Zappa The six decades spanning 1920 to 1980 describe more than just a chronological segment in the history of music; they represent a tectonic shift in the Western cultural psyche, mirroring the migration of music's epicenter from Europe to America. The period was one of ...
Continue Reading...Deconstructing Free Jazz
by Robert J. Lewis
In the continuously evolving history of artistic expression, certain movements emerge that challenge the very foundations of our aesthetic sensibilities. In the early and mid-20th century, Expressionism and free jazz were two audacious musics that not only broke all the rules but broke the spirit of many well-intentioned listeners. If the terms are not quite interchangeable, Expressionism and free jazz share a common genesis that goes back to the early 20th century with the introduction of the 12-tone ...
Continue Reading...Improvisation Versus Composition
by Robert J. Lewis
What is it that attracts music lovers to jazz (improvised music)? Is it the loose structure, or the beat or the notes and melodies we have never heard before and will never hear again, unless the performance has been recorded? Or is it the musician's uncanny ability to spontaneously translate feelings that inform the notes into the language of music? Perhaps it is the musician's audacity and courage --daring to play without a script; to make it up as he ...
Continue Reading...Listening To Music On Its Own Terms Fallacy
by Robert J. Lewis
It is an all-too common complaint. The under-appreciated or ignored composer/songwriter accuses the listener of not engaging with the work 'on its own terms.' It sounds straightforward, but the accusation is packed with all sorts of tangled ideas about what a listener's job is, and whether art has some kind of fixed value. When the composer speaks of having to listen to music on its own terms, he invariably conjures a specific, often rigid, paradigm of ...
Continue Reading...Jazz Riffs Amidst the Rubble: How Ukraine's Artists Keep Jazz Alive in Wartime
by Cheptoo Kositany
In bomb shelters, makeshift clubs, and even occasionally on the front lines, Ukrainian jazz artists are keeping the flame of the music alive. The story of jazz in Ukraine is long and winding, stretching back to the Soviet era. In the 1920s and '30s, jazz seeped into the Soviet Union, brought by records, radio broadcasts, and visiting musicians. Despite the ideological disapproval of the Communist Party, which viewed jazz as decadent Western music, it found a dedicated audience, ...
Continue Reading...The Cinderella So Few Got to Hear: Late Artie Shaw is the Best Artie Shaw
by Richard J Salvucci
Artie Shaw will always be a bit of a puzzle to his fans--"morons, as he once characterized some of us. The best band he ever fronted, and said so more than once, was his 1949-50 bop" band. Benny Goodman had a similar outfit around the same time, which, like Shaw's, featured excellent young musicians who were comfortable with the bop idiom. But as for the clarinet playing, Goodman's remained more swing than bop, while Shaw's was arguably the other ...
Continue Reading...


