Secret Jazz: The Swinging Side of Western Swing
“ ...A bastard child that neither ountry nor jazz is willing to accept into their own house. ”
Western Swing is a musical genre wonderfully described by its leading historian Cary Ginell as "a bastard child that neither country nor jazz is willing to accept into their own house. In my opinion they are an important part of both genres." Jazz historian Ted Gioia in this thoughtful The History of Jazz, while also omitting any mention of Western Swing, does address a key reason for its neglect among jazz listeners:
For example, most chronicles of musical activity in the 1920s will draw an implicit delineation between popular music, jazz, and classical composition. Hence, accounts of jazz tend to present a polarized landscape in which hot bands (Henderson, Ellington, Goodman, Basie) thrive, develop, and change in complete isolation from other musical currents. Such categorizations may make the narrative structure of a music history book flow more smoothly, but much is lost in the process.
Strange to tell, I heard an album of Bob Wills and the Texas Playboys, the best known Western Swing band of all time, the same year I first heard a Coltrane album. Who I was many decades ago could not have allowed myself to conceive of Bob Wills and John Coltrane as belonging to the same musical universe. True, I heard Wills as a creator of eccentric mutation of big band swing, but the steel guitar and fiddles? And, oh, they looked so Texan redneck on the album photo, so unhip.
Age brings with it an appreciation of musical hybrids, those defined out by academic music histories as well as those predicated on reverse-racist stereotypes. 'The pure products of America go crazy,' wrote the esteemed poet William Carlos Williams, and if America has produced 'pure' musical products unique to its national identity, Western Swing must be counted among them. Part of its purity of form is its wholehearted embrace of jazz.
The simplest way to define the genre is to identify it as a style evolving from a hybridization of black and white Southwestern string band styles encompassing a broad variety of jazz, blues, and country music characteristics. Strings bands began in several parts of the country with fiddlers and guitarists performing a variety of old folk, blues, and minstrel tunes. When Milton Brown and his Musical Brownies, the subject of the only authoritative book on Western Swing, written by Cary Ginell, added a piano and Brown's crooning voice (think early Bing Crosby) to the string band format, Western Swing emerged. And there was one other unlikely jazz flavor instrumentally Brown added: the steel string guitar of Bob Dunn. Dunn, as unlikely as it would seem for a steel guitarist circa 1935, had as his musical idol the great jazz trombonist Jack Teagarden. So he improvised on steel guitar with Teagarden's trombone sound in mind. And less we neglect the piano man, Fred 'Papa' Calhoun certainly performed with a sophisticated awareness of Jelly Roll Morton and Earl Hines.
You can hear the results on a variety of multi-disc compilations from the Origin Jazz Library label and the U.K. budget label Proper, but for those wanting the jazzier side of Milton Brown and his Musical Brownies, I strongly advise trying the single disc compilation, Western Swing Chronicles Volume 1: Milton Brown and his Musical Brownies (Origin Jazz Library). The complete recorded works can be tough going for those who find vaudevillian humor and hillbilly antics a bit wearying in extended does. But Brown's stunning version of 'St. Louis Blues,' with a tension packed accelerating crescendo as unexpected as beguiling, makes enduring some of the sweetly sentimental country numbers on this single disc very tolerable. The hard swinging instrumental improvisations on piano and steel guitar and the simply crazed, Cab Calloway-like scat vocals on the up tempo jazzy numbers like 'Some of these Days' and 'Washington & Lee Swing' are timeless gems of 30s jazz. Painstaking remastering along with well-written liner notes make this an extraordinary package for a Western Swing novice.
Brown's tragic death in an auto accident led to the band's demise in the late 30s, but soon after Bob Wills and his Texas Playboys brought their own focus to Western Swing. Fiddler Wills, recording alongside of Brown in The Light Crust Doughboys, added to Brown's formula by adding a substantial horn section and adding vocalist Tommy Duncan, a singer with a freer rhythmic sense than Brown. Wills and Brown would often engage in a silly patter interrupting song lyrics with asides a la Fats Waller. The jazzier side of Bob Wills is easily found on any of the nine volumes comprising The Tiffany Transcriptions, radio studio recordings of the late '40s on the Rhino label. Covers of big band standards by Basie and Glenn Miller pop out from several discs, but the highpoint might be the jaw-dropping, good-humored cover of the Ellington-Strayhorn masterpiece, 'Take the A Train' on Volume Three that gallops along like a Texas appaloosa goofy on peyote.