All About Jazz: The web's most comprehensive jazz resource

Serving jazz worldwide since 1995
All About Jazz: The web's most comprehensive jazz resource

CD/LP/Track Review

Kirk MacDonald: Symmetry (2014)

By Published: January 12, 2014
Kirk MacDonald: Symmetry Following two splendid albums as leader of his own big band (Deep Shadows, Family Suite for Large Jazz Orchestra), Toronto-based saxophonist / educator Kirk MacDonald has returned to a small-group format for Symmetry, the thirteenth recording on which his name has been listed atop the marquee. In this case, however, any member of MacDonald's quintet could have easily laid claim to the honor, as every one is an all-star in his own right, from the renowned trumpeter Tom Harrell
Tom Harrell
Tom Harrell
b.1946
trumpet
, who shares the front line, to the exemplary rhythm section comprised of pianist Brian Dickinson, bassist Neil Swainson
Neil Swainson
Neil Swainson
b.1955
and drummer Dennis Mackrel.

Granted, assembling five world-class musicians in a studio to record doesn't always pay dividends. Here, however, the idea seems truly inspired, thanks in part to their easygoing rapport and in even larger measure to MacDonald's admirable compositions and arrangements, which bring out the best his colleagues have to offer. In the liner notes, MacDonald writes that he was searching for "beauty as a result of balance or harmonious arrangement." Mission accomplished, starting with the shapely title selection and continuing through the nimble finale, "Bop Zone." MacDonald later amplifies the remark, pointing out the genesis and form of each arrangement, but that is best left for musicologists to read and assimilate. Suffice to say that MacDonald has readily achieved his purpose.

"Bop Zone" is especially well-suited to MacDonald whose robust, darting tenor solos bring to mind such bop-era (and later) flame-throwers as Hank Mobley
Hank Mobley
Hank Mobley
1930 - 1986
sax, tenor
, Johnny Griffin
Johnny Griffin
Johnny Griffin
1928 - 2008
sax, tenor
, Teddy Edwards
Teddy Edwards
Teddy Edwards
1924 - 2003
sax, tenor
, George Coleman
George Coleman
George Coleman
b.1935
sax, tenor
, Harold Land
Harold Land
Harold Land
1928 - 2001
sax, tenor
and Charlie Rouse
Charlie Rouse
Charlie Rouse
1924 - 1988
sax, tenor
, among others, not to mention such contemporaries as Lew Tabackin
Lew Tabackin
Lew Tabackin
b.1940
sax, tenor
, Don Menza
Don Menza
Don Menza
b.1936
saxophone
, Joe Lovano
Joe Lovano
Joe Lovano
b.1952
saxophone
and Canada's own Pat LaBarbera. As for Harrell, he is as always a model of tastefulness and consistency on trumpet or flugel, pouring years of invaluable discipline and experience into every persuasive solo. Dickinson and Swainson make the most of their moments in the sun (each is bright and perceptive whether out front or lending support), while Mackrel toils earnestly to help keep the rhythm sharp and steady. Even though no one is likely to end the day humming any of MacDonald's themes, all are well-honed and consistently pleasing.

In sum, Symmetry more than lives up to its eurythmic name: a burnished and cohesive group endeavor whose whole is actually greater than its parts. Definitely worth checking out.


Track Listing: Symmetry; Eleven; Common Ground; Mackrel’s Groove; Shadows; Brazil Like; Labyrinth; Greenwich Time; Contemplation; Bop Zone.

Personnel: Kirk MacDonald: leader, composer, arranger, tenor saxophone; Tom Harrell: trumpet, flugelhorn; Brian Dickinson: piano; Neil Swainson: bass; Dennis Mackrel: drums.

Record Label: Addo Records



comments powered by Disqus