Quantcast
NEWS |
Return to home page





Folk Songs for Jazzers
Frank Macchia
Spanish Breeze
Thomas Lorenzo, Alphonso Johnson, Walfredo Reyes, Dave Garfield
Here In the Moment
Gail Pettis
Room 13
Yair Loewenson Trio
Freefall
The Chuck Anderson Trio
Where Is Love?
Kelley Suttenfield



Trio Reenactment
Info | Enter
Dave King
Info | Enter
Frank Macchia
Info | Enter
Kurt Rosenwinkel
Info | Enter




Live Reviews | Published: October 30, 2009

Melody Gardot at the Kimmel Center


By Victor L. Schermer
Discuss (4)    

[1] 2 | Next Page

Melody Gardot
The Kimmel Center for the Performing Arts
Philadelphia, PA
October 17, 2009

"A Star is Born" is the only adequate way to characterize singer-composer Melody Gardot's appearance on the stage of the Perelman Theater of the Kimmel Center in Philadelphia on October 17. While the recent buzz surrounding her debut recordings are all about her fine jazz and blues vocalizing with a sensual flair, neither the media spin nor her first two albums prepare one for the power, resilience, and charisma she manifests in a live performance. Simply put, in concert Gardot has the reach and grandness of a Judy Garland or Edith Piaf. She took over the stage, the instrumentalists, the audience, and the music, making each into a vehicle for her own creative expression—something only a true diva can accomplish.

Regarding Gardot's approach as a jazz singer, the comparison that comes to mind is with Nina Simone, who cut her teeth playing piano in small Philadelphia clubs as did Gardot several decades later. The 26-year-old Gardot, like Simone, is musically astute, has a will of her own, and a knack for incorporating diverse musical and world influences into her singing and composing. Both artists are strongly rooted in the blues and, in Gardot's case, rhythm-and-blues. And both have a unique style and "message" that distinguishes them from their peers. Although, unlike Simone, she's not African American, she knows her own pain, and conveys in her music something important about marginalization and the human condition.

Gardot, in addition, has a command of the stage that is rare and unforgettable. At this concert, she more than made up for a puzzling, unexplained delay in the program and personnel changes from the Playbill listing. Coming on a capella as a sexy blonde Parisian blonde bombshell with a touch of Madonna, she provided her own powerful rhythm by stomping her stiletto heels on the wooden stage and snapping her fingers in the air like a flamenco dancer, as she sang "No More My Lord," with unrelenting intensity. Next she introduced her sidemen, Irwin Hall on sax, clarinet, and flute, Ken Pendergast on bass, and Chuck Staab on drums for a rhythmic performance of "The Rain," from her new CD, My One and Only Thrill. By this time, Gardot had the audience in the palm of her hands as she sang two more numbers from that album, "Your Heart is as Black as Night" and "Les Etoiles." The French influence became apparent in her cabaret styling on some choruses with electrifying echoes of Piaf's fast vibrato and slight downward glissandos.

Gardot's musical swagger became evident as well in her choice of musicians. Bassist Pendergast and drummer Staab are top of the line "locals" and threw themselves into the music with devotion. Reed player Hall is someone Gardot discovered while on tour in Japan. He shone in his solo on Rodgers and Hart's "My Funny Valentine," showing a mastery of both traditional and modern jazz idioms with an understated sound that highlighted the originality of his improvisation. At one point, reminiscent of multi-reedist Rahsaan Roland Kirk, he played two saxophones simultaneously, though his musical sensitivity, like Kirk's, was more impressive than the prestidigitation alone. He performed both backup and solos reflectively and with a sophisticated grasp of harmonies and melodic lines.

Gardot returned to her Thrill CD with two originals, "Baby I'm a Fool" and "If the Stars Were Mine," interspersed with "Pretend I Don't Exist." She then proceeded to the title tune of her debut CD, Worrisome Heart , followed by "Love Me Like a River Does" from the same album. It is remarkable that Gardot writes not just a few but nearly all of the songs she sings. She has said that writing music is therapy for the injuries and brain disorder she sustained in a bicycle accident in 2003 when she was hit by an automobile. Here again, her musical capabilities proved remarkable, as her songs magically conveyed the impression of being "standards" on account of their expressive melodic qualities and the universal meanings of her lyrics. Two more songs from Thrill—"Deep Within the Corners of My Mind" and "Who Will Comfort Me"—further reflected her emotional depth and world music awareness. When she picked up the guitar for Harold Arlen's "Somewhere Over the Rainbow," she presented it as an homage to her grandmother, who exposed her repeatedly in childhood to doses of The Wizard of Oz. The quietness of her rendition, which contrasted with the intensity of her performance up until then, seemed to give a gentle nod to Judy Garland.

Following a standing ovation, Gardot and her group did a rocking and dramatic encore of Ellington-Tizol's "Caravan," reminding the thrilled audience that, although she includes numerous genres, her roots are in straight-ahead jazz.


[1] 2 | Next Page

Melody Gardot at All About Jazz



More Melody Gardot Links


Post your comment on:
Melody Gardot at the Kimmel Center

Valerie Bishop wrote on 2009-10-30 12:02:18:

thanks for the sensitive review. i cannot wait to hear Ms. Gardot in person. have truly appreciated what i've heard on the radio and have also heard very positive reviews from friends who have experienced her live.

Lodge a complaint about this post 

Michelle Williams wrote on 2009-11-12 04:09:06:

Just as the article says Melody is a truly exeptional artiste. I have 2 spare tickets for her show in Edinburgh for 18th November 2009. If you would like more details please email me lil.elle@hotmail.co.uk

Lodge a complaint about this post 

Guy R wrote on 2009-11-25 13:39:33:

I saw her at the last Montreal Jazz Fest.
she is a phenomenon, holds you in suspense from the minute she walks in with her elegant walking cane, until you realize the show's over and you don't want to let her get off the stage.

Lodge a complaint about this post 

Chris Weed wrote on 2010-01-04 17:00:33:

A couple of notes on this review may be of interest to some readers:

1) Drummer Chuck Staab and reed player Irwin Hall are 2007 graduates of Princeton University, where they studied and worked with the great jazz educator Anthony Branker (http://www.allaboutjazz.com/php/musician.php?id=18217), and visited Estonia with Branker in 2006 as part of Princeton’s Jazz Composers Collective.

2) Two songs on 'My One and Only Thrill', including the iTunes bonus track "Pretend I Don't Exist" mentioned above, were co-written with Jesse Harris, best known for his collaborations with Norah Jones and singer-songwriter Rebecca Martin (in the latter case, early in their respective careers). [See the Wikipedia article on the album.]

Lodge a complaint about this post 

Signup & post a comment!
Read more comments (4)


Related Video





More articles by Victor L. Schermer

Live at the 55 Bar
Peter Nero: The Laughter and The Challenges
Mickey Roker: You Never Lose the Blues
Monkadelphia at Chris' Jazz Cafe
Profile




More Articles | More Live Reviews

Chris Jentsch: Cycles and Reflecting on the Journey
February 2010
Who Owns Music?
Take Five With Rick Stone
Polar Bear: Raw and Spontaneous





 
(84)




Gene Harris

Sweet Georgia Brown
From Another Night in London

More | Recent | Top









Advertise | Contact Us | Site Map |


All material copyright © 2010 All About Jazz and/or contributing writer/visual artist. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy