Soothsayers Meet The Red Earth Collective: One More Reason (2009)
One More Reason stays with the program, but this time, as the sleeve art signals, the accent is less on jazz and Afrobeat, and more on reggae and dub. Roots vocalists Johnny Clarke, Michael Prophet, Linval Thompson and Bob Skeng are featured on five tracks, Mad Professor and Nick Manasseh contribute two dub versions, and Manasseh does the mix down. Jamaica and its London diaspora are the album's dominant cultural presences.
So far, so good, if reggae is your thing. The downside is that One More Reason is less of a hybrid than its predecessors, more mono-cultural. This time out, Soothsayers has narrowed its stylistic focus and, disappointingly, is more reverential with its source material: there's plenty of invention around the edges, but less of the band's glorious, trademark miscegenation in the center.
There are, nonetheless, some fine moments. The upbeat "Music" reveals guest keyboardist Zoe Rahman, sister of Soothsayers' co-leader, reed player Idris Rahman, and an acoustic jazz pianist of substance, as a seriously funky electric player. Zoe shines in similar style on "River Effra," Soothsayers' mellow but muscular tribute to ska and the Skatalites, featuring Trevor Edwards' post-Don Drummond trombone. "Mama Said" is the album's sole bona fide F1 hybrid, its insistent little tune shared, incongruously but delightfully, between Bob Skeng and Idris Rahman on bass clarinet. The Michael Prophet showcase, "Tears Of Sorrow," a bleak lament on the consequences of gun culture, has weight and a strong tune, and Nick Manasseh's closing "Tears In Dub" makes the most of both qualities. The album's sole Afrobeat track, "Slow Down," has some exciting work from Idris Rahman on tenor saxophone and the other Soothsayers' co-leader, Robin Hopcraft, on trumpet. "Irie," warmly sung by Mellow Baku, is charming, kind of "Uptown Top Ranking" with a message.
All this adds up to plenty of good music. But the sum, this time, is not greater than its parts.
Track Listing: Intro; We Better Learn; Bad Boys; Slow Down; Tears Of Sorrow; Irie; Hold On; Mama Said; Your Love; River Effra; History; We Must Return To Dub; Tears In Dub.
Personnel: Idris Rahman: saxophone, bass clarinet, vocals; Robin Hopcraft: trumpet, flugelhorn, vocals; Johnny Clarke: vocals (4, 10); Mellow Baku: vocals (7, 8); Michael Prophet: vocals (6); Bob Skeng: vocals (9); Linval Thompson: vocals (12). Collective personnel: Dan Hewson: trombone; Trevor Edwards: trombone; Zoe Rahman: keyboards; Phil Dawson: piano, guitar; Adrian Mackenzie: keyboards; Robert Bailey: keyboards; Lucky Ranku: guitar; Derek Johnson: guitar; Andy Gibson: oud; Kodjovi Kush: guitar, bass; Neville Malcolm: bass; Momo Hafsi: bass; Wesley Johnson: drums; Patrick Illingworth: drums; Frank Tontoh: drums; Adesose Wallace: percussion; Satin Singh: percussion; Crispin Robinson: percussion.
Record Label: Red Earth Records
Style: Beyond Jazz