Phil Minton: No Doughnuts in Hand (2008)
This album is the third part of an astonishing trilogy, following A Doughnut In Both Hands (1975-1982) (Emanem, 1998) and A Doughnut In One Hand (FMP, 1998). With its title, Minton seems to have heeded the advice he gave as a track title on In Both HandsToo Many Doughnuts Make You Ill.
Minton himself notes that, "I would prefer to sing with other people and most of the time that's what I do, but it seems every ten years or so I need to sing a few songs on my own." The nature of these songs is as eccentric as the album titles. While there are obvious strands of continuity from those earlier albums, seemingly gone forever are the full-blooded vocal performances of 1975-1982, replaced by a far more exploratory, experimental approach to voice. The vocal improvisations hereranging in length from twenty-four seconds to just under three minutes are songs only in the sense that they employ the human voice. The sole exception is "Vo Be Dayish," an improvisation on a transcription by Veryan Weston of an improvisation by Phil Minton, which verges on scat singing, albeit employing non-standard vocal technique.
Non-standard vocal technique barely does justice to the rest of the tracks: "Para Five" and "Para Plus" sound like nothing so much as two cats hissing and fighting; on the twenty-two tracks in the "No Doughnuts In Hand" series, Minton variously sounds like a chronic asthmatic, someone speaking in tongues, someone with a speech impediment, a heart attack victim, a Looney Tunes cartoon character, Mr. Bean, a Tuvan throat singer, a signal generator... a dazzlingly surreal array of sounds that belie the fact that they were all created by one human voice. These are sounds from the outer limits of vocal technique; listeners should not lightly be tempted to try to imitate them, unless they crave a sore throat or worse!
The tracksrecorded over two days in April 2007 by Westonare presented in the order they were performed and recorded. This makes it fascinating to hear the evolution and development of Minton's ideas and techniques, as he returns to further explore past themes. The "Breath Out" series of seven short tracks is particularly innovatory, as Minton investigates the results possible with the exhalation of a single breath. Is this the end of the series, or can we anticipate Minus One Doughnut In Hand? Let's hope so.
Track Listing: No Doughnuts in Hand 1; No Doughnuts in Hand 2; No Doughnuts in Hand 3; No Doughnuts in Hand 4; No Doughnuts in Hand 5; No Doughnuts in Hand 6; Para Five; No Doughnuts in Hand 7; No Doughnuts in Hand 8; No Doughnuts in Hand 9; No Doughnuts in Hand 10; No Doughnuts in Hand 12; No Doughnuts in Hand 13; No Doughnuts in Hand 14; No Doughnuts in Hand 15; No Doughnuts in Hand 16; No Doughnuts in Hand 17; No Doughnuts in Hand 18; No Doughnuts in Hand 19; Short Wilkins; Vo Be Dayish; No Doughnuts in Hand 20; No Doughnuts in Hand 21; No Doughnuts in Hand 22; Breath Out One; Breath Out Two; Breath Out Three; Breath Out Four; Breath Out Five; Eyeful; Team Spirit; Para Plus; Rubbish; Breath Out Again; And Again; I Have Given This Much More Thought Than Blair Did Before He Decided To Invade Iraq.
Personnel: Phil Minton: solo voice.