All About Jazz: The web's most comprehensive jazz resource

Serving jazz worldwide since 1995
All About Jazz: The web's most comprehensive jazz resource

CD/LP/Track Review

Various Artists: People Take Warning! Murder Ballads and Disaster Songs, 1913-1938 (2008)

By Published: February 20, 2008
Various Artists: People Take Warning! Murder Ballads and Disaster Songs, 1913-1938 Ever since the Titanic sunk we have been fascinated by this disaster, memorializing it in several books, television shows, and movies. But long before Leonardo DiCaprio was born, the earliest pioneers of records were cutting musical eulogies to the passengers of the ship. These balladeers were the tabloid writers of the day, often stretching the truth for dramatic effect, but who cared? What mattered was the emotional content of the song, and if a message about the hubris of man could be included at the end, that was all for the better.

People Take Warning!: Murder Ballads and Disaster Songs, 1913-1938 collects some of the earliest recorded music, all of which deal with people meeting an untimely demise. During the Depression there was an insatiable demand for these records, some due to the ghoulish nature of the crimes, such as men killing their pregnant lovers, or merely to make sure that the victims of tragedies did not go forgotten. Often these songs contained a moral or warning, particularly those dealing with the price of technological progress through train wrecks, or those who reminded their listeners of the power of God through floods and boll weevils.

The collection is divided into three discs: "Man vs. Machine," "Man vs. Nature," and "Man vs. Man." Each of these is a fascinating excursion in ethnomusicology. Many of these songs were quickly written, sometimes using a borrowed tune and featuring hastily written lyrics, as there was no time for craftsmanship in the hurry to rush the records out into the market. They feature the simplest of accompaniment, usually banjos, violins, and guitars, and frequently only a couple of musicians perform each track. Very few are accomplished musicians or singers, at least not by today's standards. Yet this was a time when music still performed a social function in the transmission of values and important stories, and that was something that almost anyone could do.

What you will hear is early folk music akin to Alan Lomax's work, a collection that admittedly has a very narrow audience. But give this collection a listen and you'll hear some startling work. It's interesting to see how it all plays out; the "Man vs. Nature" recordings seem to feature the best melodies, whereas the "Man vs. Man" disc features some of the most coldly matter of fact recordings you'll ever hear. Clarence Ashley's "Naomi Wise" is absolutely terrifying, and it's a sure bet that at least a couple of recordings on each disc will grip you with their great stories told through simple melodies.

As you may guess the sound quality of these recordings isn't the best, but that isn't due to the remastering as much as the quality of the source material. Some of these come from records that probably took quite a bit of searching to uncover and weren't in the best shape (although some would argue that the hiss and pop only adds to the charm). However, it's amazing that these obscure recordings have lasted at all; surely no one at the time would have though that almost a century later their recordings would still be around.

Tompkins Square has certainly come up with a captivating way to release these early recordings. The stories behind each are captured in brief annotation of each song. Add an introduction by Tom Waits and a historical essay by Henry "Hank" Sapoznik and fantastic packaging (the cover painting is too cool) and it's easy to see why this collection was nominated for a Grammy for best Historical Recording. They have continued the work of the original artists by helping preserve the legacies of those who died too early. Although they have died too, their legacy lives on through the fascinating collection.


Track Listing: CD1: Titanic Blues: Hi Henry Brown & Charlie Jordan; Wreck of the old 97: Skillet Lickers; Bill Wilson: Birmingham Jug Band; The Crash of the Akron: Bob Miller; The Fate of the Talmadge Osborne: Ernest Stoneman: El Mole Rachmim: Cantor Joseph Rosenblatt; The Wreck of the Virginian: Alfred Reed; Fate of Will Rogers and Wiley Post: Bill Cox; Down Wit the Old Canoe: Dixon Brothers; Wreck of Number 52: Cliff Carlisle; Kassie Jones Part 1: Furry Lewis; Kassie Jones Part 2: furry Lewis; The Brave Engineer: Carver Boys; The Sinking of the Titanic: Richard "Rabbit" Brown; Fate of Chris Lively and Wife: Blind Alfred Reed; Wreck of the Mountain Road: Red Fox Chasers; The Unfortunate Brakeman: Kentucky Ramblers; Altoona Freight Wreck: Riley Puckett; The Fatal Wreck of the Bus: Mainers Mountaineers; Last Scene of the Titanic: Frank Hutchison; Casey Jones: Skillet Lickers; The Wreck of the Westbound Airliner: Fred Pendleton; The Titanic: Ernest Stoneman; When That Great Ship Went Down: William & Versey Smith. CD2: The Story of the Mighty Mississippi: Ernest Stoneman; Mississippi Heavy Water Blues: Robert Hicks; Dixie Boll Weevil: Fiddlin' John Carson; Mississippi Boweavil: Charlie Patton; Ohio Prison Fire: Bob Miller; Memphis Flu: Elder Curry; Explosion in the Fairmount Mine: Blind Alfred Reed; Storm That Struck Miami: Fiddlin' John Carson; When the Levee Breaks: Kansas Joe & Memphis Minnie; Alabama Flood: Andrew Jenkins; Burning of the Cleveland School: J.H. Howell's Carolina Hillbillies; High Water Everywhere Part 1: Charlie Patton; High Water Everywhere Part 2: Charlie Patton; Ryecove Cyclone: Martin & Roberts; McBeth Mine Explosion: Cap, Andy, & Flip; Dry Well Blues: Charlie Patton; Baltimore Fire: Charlie Poole; Tennessee Tornado: Uncle Dave Moon; Dry Spell Blues, Part 2: Son House; The Santa Barbara Earthquake: Green Bailey; The Death of Floyd Collins: Vernon Dalhart; The Porto Rico Storm: Carson Robison Trio; Boll Weavil: W.A. Lindsay & Alvin Condor; The Flood of 1927: Elders McIntosh & Edwards. CD3: Peddler and His Wife: Hayes Shepherd; The Little Grave in Georgia: Earl Johnson; Kenny Wagoner's Surrender: Ernest Stoneman; Henry Clay Beattie: Kelly Harrell; The Murder of the Lawson Family: Carolina Buddies: Naomi Wise: Clarence Ashley; Railroad Bill: Will Bennett; Frankie: Dykes Magic City Trio; Trial of Richard Bruno Hauptmann, Part 1: Bill Cox; Trial of Richard Bruno Hauptmann, Part 2: Bill Cox; Lanse Des Belaires: Dennis McGee & Ernest Fruge; Darling Cora: B.F. Shelton; Billy Lyons and Stack O' Lee: Furry Lewis; Tom Dooley: Grayson and Whitter; The Story of Freda Bolt: Floyd Country Ramblers; Pretty Polly: John Hammond; Fingerprints Upon the Windowpane: Bob Miller; The Bluefield Murder: Roy Harvey & The North Carolina Ramblers; Frankie Silvers: Ashley & Foster; Fate of Rhoda Sweeten: Wilmer Watts; Dupree Blues: Willie Walker; Poor Ellen Smith: Dykes Magic City Trio.

Personnel: Various - see above.

Record Label: Tompkins Square

Style: Beyond Jazz



comments powered by Disqus