Quantcast
NEWS |   Sign In   |   I'm New Here
Return to home page





Go and Find
Leanne Weatherly
This Heart of Mine
Pamela Hines
In Between Moods
Tony Foster
Moods
Michaela Rabitsch & Robert Pawlik Quartet
Shambhala
Susan Wylde
First Steps
Min Rager




GR8 - In Stock Now!
Grado Ear Buds






Pete McCann
Info | Enter
Gretchen Parlato
Info | Enter
Henry Threadgill
Info | Enter
Keith Jarrett
Info | Enter

I Have the Room Above Her
Paul Motian | ECM Records (2005)


By John Kelman
Comments        

While he has recorded for the label on albums including Paul Bley's Not Two, Not One and, more recently, Marilyn Crispell's Storyteller , it has been twenty years since drummer Paul Motian last recorded under his own name for ECM. His last recording as a leader, 1984's It Should Have Happened a Long Time Ago , was responsible for launching the trio that has perhaps best defined his singular vision and certainly represents the largest percentage of his oeuvre. But it was on a series of recordings for JMT where the trio really came into its own.

Or so one would have thought. Now, with the release of I Have The Room Above Her , Motian returns to ECM with an album that may be the best of his trio recordings with saxophonist Joe Lovano and guitarist Bill Frisell. It also re-establishes his working relationship with label owner/producer Manfred Eicher and, in the process, offers something that will be familiar to long-time fans, but subtly different as well.

What is truly remarkable is how each member's musical personality, honed in such different contexts when left to their own devices, melds into a distinctive collective personality when placed together. There's little of the Americana that has so occupied Frisell's interest in recent years, but subtle tinges emerge on tunes like "Odd Man Out," which begins with a simple folksy premise but ultimately yields the more oblique nature that earmarks the best of Motian's writing: indirect, yet gently lyrical at the same time. And Lovano's more extroverted work on his own projects may be more restrained here, but it simply demonstrates a more delicate and elegant sense of adventure, especially on "Dance," which revisits a piece from Motian's '78 recording of the same name.

Motian, as always, is a master of understatement and avoiding the obvious. Never content to be a mere timekeeper, his conception for the trio has always been one of democratic interplay, where every player is a colourist. But this record seems even more about texture than usual. The album has an intriguing narrative arc, the first half being more ethereal and introspective, starting with "Osmosis Part III," which, with its languid theme and Frisell's subtle use of looping, approaches a more spacious ambience than anything the trio has done previously. From "Dance" forward, the trio takes a relatively more assertive stance, but retains a certain open-ended approach that makes it a perfectly sensible evolution from the first half. And it's great to see an emphasis on Motian's writing—other than the title track and Monk's "Dreamland," all of the compositions are his.

Eicher's touch seems to motivate the trio to even more ambiguity than usual, but Motian's thematic sketches give every piece weight and substance, even at their most intangible. I Have The Room Above Her is the first of a number of recordings with Motian slated for release on ECM in coming months, and it's a suitably intrepid yet understated return to the fold.

Visit Universal Classics on the web.


Track listing: Osmosis Part III; Sketches; Odd Man Out; Shadows I Have the Room Above Her; Osmosis part I; Dance; Harmony; The Riot Act; The Bag Man; One In Three; Dreamland.

Personnel: Paul Motian: drums, Bill Frisell: guitar, Joe Lovano: tenor saxophone.

Style: Modern Jazz
Published: February 04, 2005


Read more reviews of I Have the Room Above Her.


Be the first to post a comment on:
Paul Motian's I Have the Room Above Her

Signup & post a comment!


Paul Motian Calendar






More articles by John Kelman

Genesis: The Movie Box 1981-2007
The Freesong Suite
Waves Sweep the Sand
Blues Vignette
9




Recent CD Reviews
George Garzone - Among Friends George Garzone
Among Friends
Charles Tyler - Charles Tyler Ensemble Charles Tyler
Charles Tyler Ensemble
Rudi Mahall / Axel Dorner / Jan Roder / Uli Jennessen - Die Enttausschung Rudi Mahall / Axel Dorner / Jan Roder / Uli Jennessen
Die Enttausschung
Fay Victor Ensemble - The Freesong Suite Fay Victor Ensemble
The Freesong Suite
Jon Irabagon with Mike Pride - I Don't Hear Nothin' But the Blues Jon Irabagon with Mike Pride
I Don't Hear Nothin' But the Blues
Hank Jones / Oliver Jones - Pleased To Meet You Hank Jones / Oliver Jones
Pleased To Meet You

CD Review Search
Artist Name  
Album Title  
Record Label  
Author  
 




 
(45)













.. Privacy Policy | AAJ Supports: Lens Lady All material copyright © 2009 All About Jazz and/or contributing writer/visual artist. All rights reserved. Advertise | Contact Us