Peter Brotzmann: Long Story Short
How we rate: our writers tend to review music they like within their preferred genres.
Whether you have no experience with the Godfather of free jazz or you measure your Peter Brötzmann CD and LP collection in linear feet, this 5CD box curated by the German saxophonist is either a great introduction to or an affirmation of his music and influence.
Organized on the occasion of his 70th birthday, these four days of performances in November 2011, also marked the 25th anniversary of the Unlimited Festival in Wels, Austria. Brötzmann did not assemble a retrospective of his ouevre, as there were no recreations of the fabled Machine Gun (FMP, 1968) sessions, Globe Unity Orchestra, or Last Exit band (having said farewell to Sonny Sharrock in 1994), nor did he play duos with Han Bennink. He did, however, display his current tastes in music which over the last twenty years have embraced musicians not only from Europe but also from Chicago and Japan.
Brötzmann's Chicago Tentet performed twice at the festival and two lengthy pieces are presented here. The first is an eerie 26-minute performance with Danish saxophonist John Tchicai, who passed away within a year of this recording. He can be heard chanting "Everything can happen from one second to the next." The second was the Tentet's "Concert For Fukushima" performance with guests Otomo Yoshihide, Akira Sakata, Michiyo Yagi and Toshinori Konda. This release only captures Yagi's koto performance, about a quarter of the two hour performance. Will there be more of this music to follow?
While Brötzmann is featured prominently here, he leads only ten out of the eighteen groups. He also choses to present his current listening pleasures. The highlights of the non-Brötzmann groups heard are several. Joe McPhee's saxophone and trumpet accompanies Morroccian Gnawa musican Maâllem Mokhtar Gania, Fred Lonberg-Holm and Michael Zerang for some African trance music. Saxophonist Mats Gustafsson, perhaps the heir to Brötzmann's sound, dabbles in bits and bites of improvisation and electronics with Dieb13 and Martin Siewert. Masahiko Satoh delivers a rollicking and cogent solo piano piece that swaps Cecil Taylor runs with stride tones and fragments of classical delivery. Brötzmann's influence can also be heard in the koto, cello and guzheng (a Chinese plucked zither) trio of Michiyo Yagi, Okkyung Lee and Xu Fengxia, as the three blast off into a freeform ethereal sound. The highlight of the non-Brötzmann ensembles might be the DKV Trio of Hamid Drake, Kent Kessler and Ken Vandermark augmented by Mats Gustafsson, Massimo Pupillo and Paal Nilssen-Love. The trio-cum-sextet sketch a restrained improvisation that is more listening than playing, before their rocked-out climax of sound.
The festival goers and connoisseurs of the great man's work are treated to various permutations and combinations of his music. His three-saxophone improvising band, Sonore, with Ken Vandermark and Mats Gustafson, marks its tenth anniversary working together here, as does the relatively new saxophone/piano/drums trio of Brotzmann, Masahiko Satoh and Takeo Moriyama. His acclaimed duo with Chicago vibraphonist Jason Adasiewicz is augmented here by drummer Sabu Toyozumi. The percussionist adds locomotion to the duo, plus he spikes the intensity.
Another new-ish Brötzmann saxophone trio, with bassist Eric Revis and drummer Nasheet Waits, is the most conventional approach heard here. Although it is far from conservative, the thirty-seven minute piece might be a nod to American free jazz as opposed to the European approach Brötzmann has championed most of his career.
The emotional and aural high points of this box set are the two pieces, one by Brotzmann's electric band Hairy Bones and the other by the African influenced ensemble that reunites him with bassist Bill Laswell. The latter piece includes Hamid Drake and guembri musican Maâllem Mokhtar Gania. While this piece hypnotizes the ear for nearly fifty-two minutes, the Hairy Bones improvisation clocking in at twenty-one minutes is an exhausting barrage of sound and energy. Toshinori Kondo's electrified trumpet and Masimo Pupillo's electric bass battle Brötzmann and drummer Paal Nilssen-Love for stage preeminence. The music is both exhilarating and exhausting.
If six hours of music could possibly leave you wanting, this collection does.
Track Listing: CD1: Sonore; Chicago Tentet with John Tchicai; Michiyo Yagi/Okkyung Lee/Xu Fengxia;
Peter Brötzmann/Masahiko Sato/Takeo Moriyama; Peter Brötzmann/Masahiko Satoh/Takeo
Moriyama. CD2: Joe McPhee/Maâllem Mokhtar Gania/Fredrick Lonberg-Holm/Michael
Zerang; Peter Brötzmann/Michiyo/Yagi/Tamaya Honda; Peter Brötzmann/Jason
Adasiewicz/Sabu Totozumi; Dieb13/Mats Gustafsson/Martin Siewert. CD3: Keiji Haino;
Peter Brötzmann/Bill Laswell/Maâllem Mokhtar Gania/Hamid Drake. CD4: Jeb Bishop/Joe
McPhee/Mars Williams/Jason Adasiewicz/Kent Kessler/Tamaya Honda; Hairy Bones;
Masahiko Satoh; Chicago Tentet wirh Michiyo Yagi “Concert For Fulushima.” CD5: Peter
Brötzmann/Eric Revis/Nasheet Waits; DKV Trio with Mats Gustafsson/Massimo Pupillo/Paal
Nilssen-Love; Full Blast; Caspar Brötzmann Massaker.
Personnel: CD1: Track 1: Ken Vandermark: reeds; Mats Gustafsson: reeds; Peter Brötzmann: reeds;
Track 2: John Tchicai: reeds; Ken Vandermark: reeds; Mats Gustafsson: reeds; Peter
Brötzmann: reeds; Kent Kessler: bass; Fred Lonberg-Holm: cello; Michael Zerang: drums;
Paal Nilssen-Love: drums; Jeb Bishop: trombone; Johannes Bauer: trombone; Joe McPhee:
trumpet; Per Åke Holmlander: tuba; Track 3: Okkyung Lee: Cello; Xu Fengxia: Guzheng;
Michiyo Yagi: koto; Track 4: Peter Brötzmann: reeds; Takeo Moriyama: drums; Masahiko
Sato: piano; CD2: Track 1: Fredrick Lonberg-Holm: cello; Michael Zerang: drums; Maâllem
Mokhtar Gania: guimbri; Joe McPhee: trumpet, saxophone; Track 2: Tamaya Honda: drums;
Michiyo Yagi: koto: Peter Brötzmann: reeds; Track 3: Peter Brötzmann: reeds; Jason
Adasiewicz: vibraphone; Sabu Toyozumi: drums; Track 4: Martin Siewert: guitar, effects,
ring stinger, electronics; Mats Gustafsson: reeds, electronics; Dieb13: turntables, effects,
cigar box; CD3: Keiji Haino: electric guitar, voice; Track 2: Peter Brötzmann: reeds; Bill
Laswell: electric bass; Maâllem Mokhtar Gania: guimbri; Hamid Drake: drums; CD4: Track
1: Kent Kessler: bass; Tamaya Honda: drums; Mars Williams: reeds; Jeb Bishop: trombone;
Joe McPhee: tenor saxophone, trumpet; Jason Adasiewicz: vibraphone; Track 2: Paal
Nilssen-Love: drums; Massimo Pupillo: electric bass; Peter Brötzmann: reeds; Toshinori
Kondo: trumpet, electronics; Track 3: Masahiko: piano; Track 4: Ken Vandermark: reeds;
Mats Gustafsson: reeds; Peter Brötzmann: reeds; Kent Kessler: bass; Fred Lonberg-Holm:
cello; Michael Zerang: drums; Paal Nilssen-Love: drums; Jeb Bishop: trombone; Johannes
Bauer: trombone; Joe McPhee: trumpet; Per Åke Holmlander: tuba; Michiyo Yagi: koto; CD5:
track 1: Peter Brötzmann: reeds; Eric Revis: bass; Nasheet Waits: drums; Track 2: Kent
Kessler: bass; Hamid Drake: drums; Paal Nilssen-Love: drums; Massimo Pupillo: electric
bass; Ken Vandermark: reeds; Mats Gustafsson: reeds; Track 3: Michael Wertmüller: drums;
Marino Pliakas: electric bass; Peter Brötzmann: reeds; Track 4: Danny Arnold Lommen:
drums; Eduardo Delgado-Lopez: electric bass; Caspar Brötzmann: guitar, voice.
Record Label: Trost Records