How we rate: our writers tend to review music they like within their preferred genres.
An elaborate box set from the Danish Storyville label: seven CDs and one DVD, paying tribute to Duke Ellington's arranger and composer Billy Strayhorn thatalasdoesn't quite live up to the ambitions of it's makers.
Ask yourself, was Strayhorn truly the shadowy figure implied by the title?
While the bulk of his work was achieved out of the public eye, Billy Strayhorn was no shrinking violet. He "subbed" for Ellington on piano with the band and played on record dates with various constellations of Ellington sidemen throughout the 1950s, most prominently as leader of the septet that in 1959 recorded "Cue For Saxophone" for British Decca (Cue being a pseudonym and contractual get-out for Johnny Hodges).
Two pictures of him adorn the cover of the Ellington band's take on The Nutcracker Suite (Phillips, 1960) on which he was given equal billing with Ellington and Tchaikovsky. During his all-too-short lifetime, Billy Strayhorn was actually one the best known composers and arrangers in jazz.
Following his death in 1967, aged 52, any shadows that might have gathered around the man's musical abilities were dispelled by Riverside's 1984 release, Great Times!, an album of Ellington/Strayhorn piano duets, recorded by Duke's son Mercer Ellington and critic Leonard Feather in the 1950s. Today Strayhorn's fame continues to grow, with videos galore posted on YouTube, including one of him playing and singing his composition "Lush Life" (attached).
If anything, it's this set thatperhaps to prove its own point?relegates Strayhorn to the shadows.
He plays only on the first of the CDs, accompanying bizarre wordless vocals in Paris in 1961 during the making of the film "Paris Blues" and in six duets with the boss, taken from the recordings made by Feather and Mercer Ellington.
He then makes a belated appearance on the DVD in footage from a concert in Copenhagen in 1965, joining the Ellington band on piano for his most famous composition, "Take The A Train," only to be upstaged by Paul Gonsalves, sound asleep over his saxophone; the drink and drugs obviously catching up with him.
The second CD, "Duke Ellington & His Orchestra Play Billy Strayhorn Compositions," jars somewhat, in that the tracks are all taken from radio transcripts. An embarrassingly "hip" MC can be heard introducing "Kissin' Bug," which Strayhorn wrote in collaboration with trumpeter Rex Stewart and vocalist Joya Sherrill, "If this next one doesn't send you out of this world, brother you just ain't born."
Is the object of the exercise simply to recycle the Duke Ellington Treasury Show recordings, which Storyville is committed to releasing in their entirety?
One way or the other, "Out Of The Shadows" is flawed. As "Take The A Train" comes round for the eighth time, even the most dedicated Strayhorn fan might doubt the wisdom of having climbed so eagerly aboard. Less would definitely have been more.
Still, the package has its moments, and some of them quite glorious. The seventh CD, taken from New York-based saxophonist Harry Allen's two-volume A Celebration Of Billy Strayhorn's Music on Jazzology, is an absolute revelation. Allen blows the dust off 14 Strayhorn numbers, propelling them into the present moment with his incisive, melodic playing. Then there's the interplay between Clark Terry (trumpet) and bassist Jimmy Woode, which turns "Satin Doll" on the DVD into a wonderfuloften very funnyjazz romp.
Highs such as these are offset by the pallid, academic fodder of CD4, "The Dutch Jazz Orchestra Plays Billy Strayhorn," in which Strayhorn compositions are played note for note and shorn of Ellington's revisions.
But, let's take it from the top...
CD1, "Billy Strayhorn, The Pianist & Composer," reveals a classically trained musician very much influenced by Ellington but with a lighter, more refined touch. There are interesting, genteel versions of "Take The A Train," "Lush Life" and the rather creepy "Strange Feeling."
The Paris String Quartet plays on "Take The A Train" and "A Flower Is A Lovesome Thing" and those weird vocals by the Paris Blue Notes creep in on "Lush Life," "Day Dream" and "Multi Colored Blue."
The second CD, "Duke Ellington & His Orchestra Play Billy Strayhorn Compositions," comprisesas notedre-hashes from the Treasury Shows broadcasts. Al Hibbler's vocal on "My Little Brown Book," positively drips with sentimentality. It's difficult to credit that it's the same song John Coltrane
"Something To Live For," was the first Strayhorn number to be recorded by the Ellington band and "Johnny Come Lately," the first song he wrote for Hodges. "Take The A Train" boasts a relatively rare tenor solo by Jimmy Hamilton and high note work by Al Killian on trumpet that presages the coming of Cat Anderson but it's a great "out-tro" by Harry Carney that steals the show.
CD3, snappily titled "Various Groups Play Billy Strayhorn," features outfits led by Clark Terry, Ben Webster, Johnny Griffin, Roy Eldridge, James Spaulding (alto) and Danish tenor ace Jesper Thilo. There are also piano interpretations by Art Tatum, Duke Jordan, Horace Parlan, Mary Lou Williams and Teddy Wilson and novelty vocal versions of "Take The A Train" and "Just A-Sittin' And A-Rockin'" by the Delta Rhythm Boys. Webster is his usual magnificent self on "Chelsea Bridge." Tatum (as always) allows his phenomenal technique to get in the way on "Just A-Sittin' And A- Rockin." While Johnny Griffin, a great, often under-rated player, turns "Isfahan" into a showstopper.
CD4 is the one by The Dutch Jazz Orchestra. The opener, "Everything Is Copasetic" was written by Strayhorn for a fund-raising concert by a group of tap-dancers called The Copasetics that he was involved with.
"Hip," "Blue House" and "Hipper-Bug" are thought to have been featured by the Ellington band at dance dates but never, for some reason, recorded. "Flame Indigo" was written for Ellington's revue "Jump For Joy." "Tiffany" and "Lozit" (Tizol spelled backwards) were unknown until unearthed from the Ellington archives by Walter de Leur, author of "Something To Live For," a book about Strayhorn's music.
CD5: "Billy Strayhorn Played By Scandinavians" (another snappy title!) is more fun than the Dutch offering. The first seven tracks feature Sweden's Rolf Ericson, who played with both the Ellington and Basie bands, on trumpet, and the next three that dependable ex-pat American Bob Rockwell on tenor. "Three And Six," is by the Stan Getz-influenced Swedish tenor player Erik Nordström.
Clarinettist Ken Peplowski's contribution on CD6, has a sleepy, occasionally downright soporific feel to it. Phil Lee's guitar adds bite, as doeson the last seven tracksthe bass playing of Alec Dankworth, son of John Dankworth and Cleo Laine.
CD7 boasts the snappiest title of the entire set: "Billy Strayhorn Played By Harry Allen, Chris Flory, Keith Ingham, Dennis Irwin, Chuck Riggs." And it's a great listening experience too. With this one, the chains of the past fall away and Ellington and Strayhorn's work breaks through to shine as brightly as if it were written yesterday. Allen converts "The Kissin' Bug" from mediocre pop song intowellsomething else, man. If it doesn't send you out of this world, brother you just ain't born. Now where's that MC when he's needed?
Track Listing: CD1: Lush Life; Just A-Sittin’ And A-Rockin’; Passion Flower; Take The
A Train; Strange Feeling; Day Dream; Chelsea Bridge; Multi Colored
Blue; Something To Live For; A Flower Is A Lovesome Thing; Tonk;
Johnny Come Lately; In A Blue Summer Garden; Tonk (Pianistically
Allied); Drawing Room Blues; Tonk.
CD2: Something To Live For; Grievin’; Johnny Come Lately; Take The A
Train; Mid-Riff; My Little Brown Book; Day Dream; Bugle Breaks;
Metronome All Out; I Don’t Mind; After All; Kissin’ Bug; Just A-
Sittin’ And A-Rockin’; Clementine; Paradise; Passion Flower; Satin
Doll; Newport Up; What Else Can You Do With A Drum; Blood Count.
CD3: Take The A Train; Chelsea Bridge; Just A-Sittin’ And A-Rockin’;
Lush Life; Isfahan; Just A-Sittin’ And A-Rockin’; Satin Doll; Take The
A Train; Johnny Come Lately; Satin Doll; Chelsea Bridge; Take The A
CD4: Everything Is Copasetic; Hip; Blue House; Hipper-Bug; Pretty
Girl; Anatomy Of A Murder; Swing Dance; Feet On The Beat; Matinee; Jo;
Flame Indigo; Fol-De-Rol-Rol; Tiffany; Orson; Lozit; Pomegranate.
CD5: The Intimacy Of The Blues; Paris Blues; The Star-Crossed Lovers;
Chelsea Bridge; Portrait Of A Silk Thread; Day Dream; Lotus Blossom;
Blood Count; Upper Manhattan Medical Group; Chelsea Bridge/Star-
Crossed Lovers/Day Dream; Passion Flower; Three And Six.
CD6: No One Knows; Lotus Blossom; Ballad For Very Tired And Very Sad
Lotus Eaters; Rain Check; Snibor; Noir Bleu; The Star-Crossed Lovers;
Something To Live For; After All; Multi Colored Blue; Mid-Riff; A
Flower Is A Lovesome Thing.
CD7: Smada; Depk; Jazz Festival Jazz; Intimacy Of The Blues; All Day
Long; Balcony Serenade; Snibor; Strange Feeling; Kissin’ Bug; Newport
Up; My Little Brown Book; Mid-Riff; I’m Checking Out, Goom Bye; Rain
DVD: Take The A Train; Mid-Riff; Chelsea Bridge; Passion Flower; Satin
Doll; Medley: Lush Life/Solitude; Take The A Train; Satin Doll; Take
The A Train.
Personnel: CD1: Billy Strayhorn, Duke Ellington: piano; Michel Gaudrey: bass;
Paris String Quartet; Paris Blue Notes: vocal.
CD2: Duke Ellington And His Famous Orchestra: Cootie Williams, Rex
Stewart, Wallace Jones, Ray Nance, Harold Baker, Shelton Hemphill, Al
Killian, Taft Jordan, Clark Terry, Herbie Jones, Mercer Ellington, Cat
Anderson: trumpet; Lawrence Brown, Juan Tizol, Joe Nanton, Tyree
Glenn, Quentin Jackson, Britt Woodman, Claude Jones, John Sanders,
Buster Cooper, Chuck Connors: trombone; Barney Bigard, Otto Hardwick,
Johnny Hodges, Harry Carney, Sax Mallard, Chauncey Haughton, Ben
Webster, Harry Carney, Jimmy Hamilton, Al Sears, Paul Gonsalves,
Russell Procope: reeds; Duke Ellington, Billy Strayhorn: piano; Fred
Guy: guitar; Billy Taylor, Jimmy Blanton, Alvin Raglin, Wendell
Marshall, Jimmy Woode, John Lamb: bass; Sonny Greer, Sam Woodyard:
drums; Al Hibbler, Marie Ellington, Joya Sherrill: vocal.
CD3: Track 1: Clark Terry: trumpet; Johnny O’Neal: piano; Dewey
Sampson: bass; James Martin: drums. Track 2: BenWebster: tenor
saxophone; Camille de Ceunynck: piano; Tony Vaes: bass; Charlie
Pauvels: drums. Track 3: Art Tatum: piano. Track 4: Duke Jordan:
piano. Track 5: Johnny Griffin: tenor saxophone; Kenny Drew: piano;
Jens Meigaard: bass; Ole Streenberg: drums. Track 6: Delta Rhythm
Boys: vocal. Track 7: Roy Eldridge: trumpet; Vic Dickenson: trombone;
Budd Johnson: tenor saxophone; Tommy Flanagan: piano; Major Holley:
bass; Eddie Locke: drums. Track 8: Delta Rhythm Boys: vocal. Track 9:
Horace Parlan: piano. Track 10: James Spaulding: alto saxophone; Cedar
Walton: piano; Steve Nelson: vibes; Sam Jones: bass; Billy Higgins:
drums. Track 11: Ben Webster: tenor saxophone; Kenny Drew: piano;
Niels-Henning Ørsted Pedersen: bass; Al Heath: drums. Track 12:
Mary Lou Williams: piano; Milton Suggs: bass; Drashear Khalid: drums.
Track 13: Jesper Thilo: tenor saxophone; Hank Jones: piano; Doug
Raney: guitar; Hugo Rasmussen: bass; Svend-Erik Nørregaard:
drums. Track 14: Teddy Wilson: piano; Hugo Rasmussen: bass; Ed
CD4: The Dutch Jazz Orchestra.
CD5: Tracks 1-7: Rolf Ericson: trumpet; Lennart Åberg: reeds;
Bobo Stenson: piano; Göran Klinghagen: guitar; Max Schultz:
guitar; Rose-Marie Åberg: vocal; Dan Berglund: bass; Egil
Johansen: drums. Track 8: Hans Ulrik: bass; Kjeld Lauritsen: organ;
Per Gade: guitar; Esben Bach: drums. Tracks 9-11: Jesper Lundgaard:
bass; Bob Rockwell: tenor saxophone; Jacob Fischer: guitar; Keith
Copeland: drums. Track 12: Erik Nordström: tenor saxophone; Jan
Zirk: piano; Kjell Jansson: bass; Magnus Gran: drums.
CD6: Tracks 1-4: Ken Peplowski: reeds; John Horler: piano; Phil Lee:
guitar. Tracks 5-12: add Alec Dankworth: bass
CD7: Harry Allen: tenor saxophone; Chris Flory: guitar; Keith Ingham:
piano; Dennis Irwin: bass; Chuck Riggs: drums.
DVD: Tracks 1-4: Duke Ellington And His Famous Orchestra: Cootie
Williams, Herb Jones, Cat Anderson, Mercer Ellington, Ray Nance:
trumpets; Lawrence Brown, Buster Cooper, Chuck Connors: trombone; Paul
Gonsalves, Jimmy Hamilton, Johnny Hodges, Russell Procope, Harry
Carney: reeds; Duke Ellington, Billy Strayhorn: piano; John Lamb:
bass; Sam Woodyard: drums. Track 5: Clark Terry: trumpet; Duke Jordan:
piano; Jimmy Woode: bass; Svend-Erik Nørregaard: drums. Track 6:
Duke Jordan: piano; Jesper Lundgaard: bass; Aage Tanggaard: drums.
Track 7: The Delta Rhythm Boys. Track 8-9: Duke Ellington And His
Famous Orchestra: Ray Nance, Shorty Baker, Cat Anderson,
Bill Berry, Ed Mullens: trumpet; Lawrence Brown, Leon Cox, Chuck
Connors: trombone; Russell Procope, Johnny Hodges, Paul Gonsalves,
Jimmy Hamilton, Harry Carney: reeds; Duke Ellington: piano; Aaron
Bell: bass; Sam Woodyard: drums.