321 Recommend It!

Stefan Keune / Hans Schneider / Achim Kramer: No Comment (2009)

By Published: | 3,871 views
Stefan Keune / Hans Schneider / Achim Kramer: No Comment Improvised music is rife with precedents in these early years of the twenty-first century, both on record and otherwise. The one for the trio of saxophone, bass and drums was set under the leadership of Sonny Rollins
Sonny Rollins
Sonny Rollins
b.1930
saxophone
over half a century ago and since then the line-up has been amply documented on record. Set against those precedents the music here covers an awful lot of ground, but in so doing perhaps loses a certain depth of identity.

Not that this is down to any shortcomings on the part of the musicians themselves. All three players are conversant in the language of free improvisation and they have the lightning-fast responses the music demands. On "Handpicked" this is manifested in small, spare gestures, with the music progressing not so much by stealth as by quasi-secret common understanding. Stefan Keune on alto saxophone sometimes lapses into Anthony Braxton

Anthony Braxton
Anthony Braxton
b.1945
reeds
's otherwise singularly stuttered vocabulary, but his phrasing is his own, especially when he puts out smeared, slightly visceral lines like a man acting the provocative agent. Paradoxically, when the energy level does rise it's as a result of collective endeavor, as opposed to that provocation.

On "Splinters" it's abundantly obvious that this is a leaderless group for all of the piece's brevity. Collectively speaking, the musicians are not in awe of the moment, but neither are they anxious to mark its passing with noise. The discussion between all three musicians is still intense, and Keune distinguishes himself on baritone sax by dint of both economy and restraint.

For Keune the utility of screaming through the large horn is severely restrictive. He proves as much even on "Rough Edges," where the discussion is more animated and Achim Kramer, the colorist, comes to the fore on drums. Hans Schneider gets as close as he ever does to maintaining a line on bass, even while his work perhaps echoes Gary Peacock

Gary Peacock
Gary Peacock
b.1935
bass
's feel for broken, irregular momentum. When animation does get the better of him, Keune equally echoes Evan Parker
Evan Parker
Evan Parker
b.1944
sax, tenor
's fractiousness.

That said, there's enough here to refute the charge that this is mere energy music. The methodology of "Spick And Span" is different entirely, and it's as if the trio began playing with a shared understanding. Such calculation as that might imply is however not part of the deal, and the music accordingly echoes the Spontaneous Music Ensemble when the line-up consisted of Trevor Watts

Trevor Watts
Trevor Watts
b.1939
saxophone
and John Stevens
John Stevens
b.1940
. It shares also a similar inscrutability of method.


Track Listing: In Layers; Handpicked; Brushes; Raw; Rough Edges; Splinters; Details; Chunks; Mesh; Spick And Span; Rapid Movement.

Personnel: Stefan Keune: sopranino sax, alto sax, baritone sax; Hans Schneider: bass; Achim Kramer: drums.

Record Label: FMP Records

Style: Free Improv/Avant-Garde


comments powered by Disqus

Weekly Giveaways

Roscoe Mitchell

Roscoe Mitchell

About | Enter

Peter Lerner

Peter Lerner

About | Enter

Jamie Saft

Jamie Saft

About | Enter

Sun Trio

Sun Trio

About | Enter

Sponsor: Nonesuch Records