Gourmet Duo / Joel Remmel Trio / Rebecca Kontus / UMA & Andi Pupato Jazzkaar Festival 2011 Tallinn, Estonia April 23-25, 2011 It may be smallboth geographically, sandwiched between the Baltic Sea and Russia, with only 159.2 square kilometers and a population of a mere 1.3 million as of its last censusbut Estonia has a cultural tradition that dwarfs many larger countries. And for a country that, until 20 years ago, spent vast chunks of its history occupied by other countries, including Denmark, Sweden, Germany, Russia, Poland (briefly) and the Soviet Union, it has retained a cultural independence engendering, over the centuries, a rich folk tradition, and a strong choral heritage that has, over the past few decades, been defined by composers including Arvo Pärt, Veljo Tormis and of Erkki-Sven Tüür.
One of Tallinn's walls, now home to an open air market
Wandering around Tallinn, the country's capital and largest city, with a little over 400,000 people, it's no surprise that it was selected as 2011 European Capital of Culture. Leaving the Sokos Hotel Viru and entering through the tower gates into the old city is, for someone living in a young country like Canada, a profound experience. There are plenty of signs of Tallinn's long historythe country first settled around 8500 BC and, prior to German invading during the 13th century, a pagan land worshipping nature spirits. The walls that fortified the city in the 13th century still remain, though they're now tourist attractions and, at their foot, home for a string of local vendors selling clothing, including handmade wool sweaters, gloves, toques and moreno surprise, given the average temperature in July is brisk 17° Celsius, and an even brisker -9° in the midst of Estonian winter.
Still, with spring upon the city, once the temperatures hit double digits the locals can be found, in huge numbers, at outdoor cafés. It may be a small city, in relative terms, but it bustles just the same, with large crowds out, even on Easter Sunday. Those of a religious persuasion could celebrate the holiday in one of a number of old churches, like St. Olaf's, a tremendous old structure with a 160 meter Gothic spire that was built in the 15th century. The Christianization of Estonia in the 13th century caused a number of magnificent structures to be built, catering to worshipers of Catholic, Russian Orthodox and Lutheran persuasionsa total of 16 structures that are reason enough to visit the city.
The Spire of St. Olaf's Church
But there's so much more. Wandering the streets of old Tallinn, it's possible to find craftspeople still practicing everything from textile to glass-making; even marzipanthat amalgam of almond and sugar that, in its early days, was considered a cure for everything from anxiety to sexual disfunctionis crafted into a myriad of shapes, while other artists build a menagerie of ceramic animals, each given their own unique names, to which the artist and owner of the shop will be happy to introduce, if only you ask.
Old and new seem to coexists comfortably, with buildings being renovated, rebuilt or newly built, amidst structures that date anywhere across the last 700 years. Kadriorg Park is home to a series of older structures, many of which have been converted to museums, near the current home of Estonia's president, Toomas Hendrik Ilves. The Kadriorg Palace, now an art gallery, was built in the 18th century by Tsar Peter I for his empress, Catherine, and is a particularly stunning structure, nestled in grounds that are now used by Tallinn residents as stunning, in-city parkland.
In addition to the many venues designed for the arts, many of these old structures are used for special presentations, and attending Jazzkaar is as good an opportunity as any to sample many of them. The first three days of the festival largely focused on Mustpeade Maja (Blackhead's Guild), a Renaissance-era structure used as a combination performance space, art gallery and museum. But as Jazzkaar moved into its second stretchone which focused even more on Estonian musiciansit also changed locations, with a full day of programming at Kadriorg Park, in seven different venues; on Easter Sunday, a tremendous performance at Oleviste Kirik (St. Olaf's Church); and, on the following day, a multimedia show at the more modern KUMU art museum.
With Jazzkaar kicking off a full afternoon of programming at a number of venues in Kadriorg Park, the emphasis on Estonian talent also demonstrated the surprising breadth of reach, surprising for such a small country. Gourmet Duo's target audience was, however, an audience whose tastes lean more to the lounge side of the jazz equation. Pianist/vocalist Yvetta Uustalu and electric upright bassist Tõnis Tüür would have been right at home in a piano bar, but here, in the lovely E. Vilde majamuuseumin a lounge converted to performance space, with chairs added to the lush couches, tables and chairs, to seat perhaps 30 peoplethe duo delivered a set heavy on standards, including music from Cole Porter
, but with a handful of Estonian songs thrown in for good measure.
Gourmet Duo, From Left: Yvetta Uustalu, Tõnis Tüür
Uustalu possessed a lovely, expressive voice, with good range and intonation; her piano work was heavy on the mainstream and, if not particularly adventurous, then certainly fitting the duo's lounge vibe, with enough flair to be impressive but enough adherence to a song's melody as to be accessible to a "jazz lite" crowd. Tüür, unfortunately, was less impressive; a fine enough timekeeper, to be sure, but with a tendency to become a little heavy handednot with bursts of virtuosity, but with sudden punctuations that were too dominant and obvious. A good ensemble player, his solos demonstrated a weaker ability to navigate the material's changes than Uusatlu, who was clearly the better-versed player.
All that said, the audience enjoyed the set; but after the more adventurous music of the past three days, Gourmet Duo's performance was simply too lightweight, too safe and too unadventurous to be more than a pleasantry. And when the duo pulled out Billy Joel's "Just the Way You Are," they crossed the line into wedding band territory. Not that there's anything wrong with that, but did they deserve a place at Jazzkaar?