How we rate: our writers tend to review music they like within their preferred genres.
Trombonist Gianluca Petrella's got impeccable credentials, having played with heavyweights like Carla Bley, Steve Swallow, Greg Osby, Flavio Boltro and Enrico Rava. His often electronically enhanced trombone sound is unique to the point of making him immediately recognizable. To his credit, he's interested in moving jazz forward by incorporating modern elements into a European jazz context with an emphasis on melodic, emotionally physical communication.
Indigo4 is a quartet set featuring Petrella, tenor man/clarinetist Francesco Bearzatti, drummer Fabio Accardi and bassist Paolino Della Porta. This collection mingles Petrella originals with treatments of Duke Ellington, Thelonious Monk and Tony Williams songs and is very much a studio creation in which Petrella doctors live performances with electronic cutups, drum loops and samples. There's a rich depth of sound that's both thickly realistic (as evidenced throughout by bassist Della Porta's thick, meaty bass and audible exhalations) and dreamily artificial (as heard in the swimming laptop effects that saturate "Two in a Hole ).
So Indigo4 is ambitious. It's modern. It's also pretty bad. At its worst ("Trinkle Tinkle ) it's downright abrasive; at its best ("Sacred Whale ) it's compositionally half-baked and harmonically dullmusic seemingly designed for designer-cocktail clubs and fatuous boutiques.
Petrella's take on Monk's "Trinkle Tinkle starts the CD off in the worst way possiblea monotonous two-note sample of the composer's own recorded piano is inserted into a rhythmically plodding soundscape in which Bearzatti's tenor and Petrella's trombone reduce the composition to a static repetition of the head that's only enlivened by sharp electronic chop-ups of the performance. It's not that it's blasphemous to drag Monk into the proceedingsit's just annoying and, if anything, outdated: strictly 1988.
"Lazy Moon, a mostly-live group performance (echo-laden electronic percussion ping-pongs occasionally around the stereo field) is marginally better, but it's deathly dulltrombone and tenor play smoky, bluesy nothings over an unvarying Accardi groove pattern. While the leader's spooky, repeated-loop lines over Della Porta's fat bass do produce a certain hypnosis on the part of the listener, the piece goes on for seven very noticeable, watch-checking minutes.
"The Middleman is built around a skittering electronica beat played live by Accardi that's impeccably executed, but again, cornily outdatedthink 1996 drum 'n' bass. Doubled, electronified Petrellas ooze and warble around the drum pattern and while the song's admirably brief at two minutes, there's a pleased-with-itself quality here that's not particularly charming.
Tony Williams' "There Comes a Time is pretty good, though. Here, Accardi's adamant, dumbed-down snare blends winningly with Della Porta's busy lines before the drummer breaks free with charging, brisk rolls as Petrella and Bearzatti play thrilling, dynamicand refreshingly emotionallines, sometimes contrapuntally.
But there's not enough of the stuff that pours out of "There Comes a Time, and a listener sitting through Indigo4 is reminded of the grandson's classic line from Rob Reiner's film The Princess Bride: "when's it get good? Electronics are great for jazz, and there are plenty of musicians using them imaginatively, but that's not happening here.
Track Listing: Trinkle Tinkle; The Middleman; Lazy Moon; Mr. Wolf; Sacred Whale; I Got It Bad; Mood Indigo; Two in a Hole; There Comes a Time; Stockholm; I.S.T.R.; A Relaxing Place on Venus (Dedicated to Sun Ra).
Personnel: Gianluca Petrella: trombone; Francesco Bearzatti: tenor saxophone, clarinet; Fabio Accardi: drums; Paolino Della Porta: bass.