How we rate: our writers tend to review music they like within their preferred genres.
The Music Matters reissue of saxophonist Sam Rivers' Fuchsia Swing Song is likely the finest pressing of this record ever produced. Remastered from the original two- track tapes, and pressed on two 180 gram 45 rpm LPs, this vinyl is dead quiet, and sonically stunning. The instruments are huge in the soundstage and the clarity blows any CD versionand likely most prior vinyl versionsout of the water. Add to that a gorgeous gatefold cover with additional session photos and thick plastic sleeve liners, and this truly ranks as a first-class, ultra deluxe edition of this 1964 Blue Note classic.
But the musicoh, that music!
Sam Rivers' first album as a leader, as well as his first album for Blue Note, blends two of the major saxophone schools of the day. By 1960, jazz tenor had been redefined by the very different playing styles of Sonny Rollins
. Rollins was (and remains to this day) a melodist at heart which, even when he was stretching out his improvisations, left them accessible and easily contextualized. On the other hand, Coltrane's genius was built on his fearless harmonic inventions, speed, and raw emotion. Rivers' achievement with Fuchsia Swing Song is how successfully he blends those two schools of performance in his own voice.
The first few bars of the opening title track are indeed a pretty, well-defined melody: very Rollins-esque with a warm, if somewhat loose, breathy delivery. But that doesn't last long. Rivers begins improvising after just one turn of the melody, immediately blending components as diverse as Coltrane's "sheets of sound," as he pushes the boundaries of his horn into false notes, before throwing in a few traditional threads of bebop. There is a lot going on in this track and Rivers' enormous skills hang it all together.
"Cyclic Episode" takes it all even further out. Opening again with a defined melody, the tune quickly pushes the boundaries of its structure as pianist Jaki Byard
uses his comping to distort the rhythm and key signature, before allowing it all to snap back into place for an aggressive Rivers solo. But when Byard takes his turn he quiets it down dramatically, slowing the tempo until, with the drums laying out, he achieves a soft, almost Bill Evans
-style melancholy before exploding back into the original theme with his own high flying improvisational statement.
The brilliance of Fuchsia Swing Song is that it's endlessly ingenious at every level. The musicians have an uncanny ability to pull and stretch every passage like taffy without actually breaking the core melodic framework of the tunes. They can be subtle, belligerent, tender, and even completely over the edge, but all of these disparate contributions become integral to one of the most thrillingly satisfying records of the era. Fuchsia Swing Song doesn't seem to garner as much attention as some of the more popular titles in the Blue Note catalog and that's a real crime because this is truly one of the finest jazz albums of the era.