Either/Orchestra: New York City, February 11, 2011
Le Poisson Rouge
New York, NY
February 11, 2011
If you graduated school to work for a law firm or a contracting company, your reunion would probably not be a raucous or joyous event. However, if you and your classmates went on to be the employees of Lee Konitz, Lester Bowie, Sam Rivers, Nnenna Freelon and Morphineand if one of you founded your own company, called Medeski, Martin & Woodthere'd certainly be cause to celebrate. This was the atmosphere at New York City's Le Poisson Rouge, during Either/Orchestra's 25th anniversary show. The both reverent and irreverent big band is one of the few longstanding legends of jazz hewn outside the New York area, hailing from the Cambridge/Boston area. Much like its New England contemporary, George Garzone's The Fringe, Either/Orchestra has taken its sound and vision to concerts halls around the world, with more than 1,000 concerts under its belt. Coming into New York to join up with many of their illustrious alumni, the Either/Orchestra made an indelible mark on new listeners and seasoned fans alike.
The band was not showing its age, or any signs of restraint. Throughout the show, the stage was bombarded with a massive number of musicians, switching and compiling unorthodox changes in personnel that would have tripped up a group one-eighth its size. On one tune in particular, every rhythm guest was playing (two bassists, three keyboardists, four drummers, a guitarist and a conguero). The horns were no exception; at its apex, the band consisted of seven saxophonists, five trombonists and three trumpeters, not to mention the occasional vocalist. The ensemble also prevailed in endurance, plowing through 14 selections in a marathon stretch of three hours, with no break, save for leader Russ Gershon's occasional introductions.
With so many years of activity and so many styles traversed, the orchestra was posed with the unique task of exhibiting its versatility in a concise program, and was undoubtedly successful. What needs to be mentioned first and foremost was the group's utmost sincerity in the styles played. For all its genre explorations, the group can swing hard. A medley of "Blue Lights/Evil Eye," taken from an obscure John Gilmore/Clifford Jordan record, was driven by a playful and energetic cymbal-heavy swing from Matt Wilson. Gershon's "One of a Kind Shimmy" was pure, unadulterated hard bop, with pianist Dan Kaufman channeling Cedar Walton and Herbie Hancock, reverberating and interacting with a Jimmy Smith-inspired John Medeski, at his wah-wah organ.
Some of the orchestra's other swinging numbers were not as polite. "Notes on a Cliff," written by trombonist and alumnus Curtis Hasselbring, featured dense chord motion and plenty of crunchy dissonance. The bluesy call-and-response dialogue between trombones and trumpets was surrounded by a whirling mania of Latin rhythms, lush backgrounds and Wilson's steely Afro-Cuban rumbles. Hasselbring shared an expressive dialogue with the drums, diving headfirst into the lowest register of his trombone. "Eulogy," a two-for-one tribute to Steve Lacy and Elvin Jones, paid its tribute to these jazz greats through musical imitation. The knotty, spiky melodies, arranged in typical bop rhythmic inventions, were cut directly from the Lacy cloth. A dual drum conversation between Wilson and Pablo Bencid paid tribute to Jones' ability to create pulse and melody from his drum set; one drummer creating pulse, while the other soloed.