How we rate: our writers tend to review music they like within their preferred genres.
The John Burnett Orchestra is a formidable swing band because, while there's undoubted reverence in their evocations of the era, that reverence is tempered by sparks of originality. Indeed, the tight-but-loose thing which summarizes its collective sound is now pretty hard to come by, which makes this release a cause for celebration.
When the band's joined by clarinetist Buddy DeFranco
on the warhorse that is "Sing Sing Sing" it's impossible to keep from smiling in view of how the balance between the reverential and the life-affirming is finely struck. In terms of dynamics there isn't much that's truly striking going on, but that's not the point. This is a band which chews up the charts, even while it doesn't go in for the kind of all-out bombast that would bring the house down for all the wrong reasons. Throw in solos by DeFranco and tenor saxophonist Frank Catalano
's "Cotton Tail" strikes a fine balance again, despite inevitably failing to scale the same heights of the original. This is no one's fault, but, rather, a testament to the inimitable and indefinable nature of Ellington's music.
A similarly indefinable thing applies to anything that the Count Basie
band laid down for posterity, causing readings of "The Heat's On," "One O'clock Jump" and the title track to lose out by comparison. Still, this is a band which knows the swing idiom inside out, ensuring that it generates enough momentum on "One O'Clock Jump" to carry itself into the White House.
"Wind Machine" is another Basie tribute which hits the spot, thanks in no small part to a tenor sax solo from Lennie Roberts and the work of drummer Bill Byan, who appropriately evokes the spirit of Sonny Payne
Ellingtonia is the order of the day again on "In a Mellow Tone," which finds the reeds sounding particularly creamy, even while proceedings are underscored by a measure of grease to keep things easy.
On a practical point it should be noted that the personnel provided here is for the band's current lineup. It's listed in the accompanying booklet, but isn't properly reflective of the artists actually performing on the disc.
Track Listing: In The Mood; In a Mellow Tone; Basically Blues; The Heat's On; Down For Double; One O'clock Jump; Wind Machine; West Side Story; Cottontail; Sing Sing Sing; Out of Nowhere; The Blues.
Personnel: Terry Connell: trumpet; Mike McGrath: trumpet; Doug Scharf: trumpet; Scott Wagstaff: trumpet; Adam Gross: trombone; Russ Phillips: trombone; Dana Legg: trombone; Bill Walsh: bass trombone; Bob Frankich: alto sax; Justin May: alto sax; Mark Colby: tenor sax; David Kublank: tenor sax; Bruce Mack: baritone sax; Frank Caruso: piano; Paul Martin: bass; Bill Byan: drums; Buddy DeFranco: clarinet.