For his Cam Jazz debut, trumpeter Ralph Alessi recruits two key players from his sadly overlooked Look
(Between the Lines, 2007). But while ubiquitous bassist Drew Gress
, Claudia Quintet
) is a mainstay of Cognitive Dissonance
, pianist Andy Milne
only guests on the knottily themed but swinging "Sir" and a quirkily, near-unrecognizable version of Stevie Wonder
's "Same Old Story." The rest of the album's fifteen trackseleven by Alessi, in addition to a free-spirited yet surprisingly lyrical version of Sam Rivers
' "Sunflower" and two collective improvs with Gress and drummer Nasheet Waits
feature pianist Jason Moran
, once again demonstrating his greater strengths as a sideman.
The same needn't be said about Alessi who, along with fellow trumpeter Ron Miles
, remains one of America's most perennially (and curiously) undervalued trumpeters. His plangent, warm and somehow compressed tone is just one compelling reason to check out bassist Scott Colley
's Architect of the Silent Moment
(Cam Jazz, 2007) (and his forthcoming 2010 Cam Jazz follow-up, Empire
), guitarist Joel Harrison
's The Wheel
(Innova, 2008) and Gress' The Irrational Numbers
(Premonition, 2008). With a relatively diminutive self-led discography, the avant-tinged trumpeter has also proven himself an astute bandleader and fine conceptualist, ranging from the oddly configured Vice & Virtue
(RKM, 2003) to the more orthodox (but far from conventional) instrumental line-up of This Against That
(RKM, 2002).Cognitive Dissonance
covers a lot of ground in an hour. The irregularly metered but unfailingly grooving
title track kicks things off on a high note, with Gress and Waits building an M-Base-centric foundation over which Moran's funkified piano sets a broad harmonic context. Alessi's impressive opening salvo sets the tone for an album where the soloists are challenged to say a great deal in a short timeframe, succeeding consistently. Despite only one track exceeding six minutes, with the majority ranging between three and four, there's never a sense of being hurried, as Alessi solos with equal invention over the even more rhythmically intricate "Buying, Selling"his even briefer solo (on a tune where the head occupies a full minute of its 2:56 running time) a muted combination of spare, swinging ideas and equal consideration of space, with Moran's staggered accompaniment leading to a similarly well-conceived solo, supported by the ever-pliant, ever-responsive Gress and Waits.
Alessi waxes lyrical on the balladic "Dog Waking" and tango-esque "One Wheeler Will," written for William Coltraneson of legendary saxophonist John Coltrane
's son (and also very fine reed man) Ravi Coltrane
. An inadvertent nod to expat Canadian trumpet icon Kenny Wheeler
in the trumpeter's tone and expressive melancholy, "One Wheeler Will" also features a robust, yet metallic and Gary Peacock
-like solo from Gress that's a Cognitive Dissonance
With so much ground covered, it would be easy for Cognitive Dissonance
to lose its focus, to become overly eclectic. But with Alessi's writinga challenging combination of memorable themes, harmonically and rhythmically tricky contexts and improvisational largessand an unfettered yet focused playing style that never succumbs to excess, Cognitive Dissonance
easily deserves consideration alongside the music of better-known contemporaries like Dave Douglas
Track Listing: Cognitive Dissonance; Buying, Selling; Dog Waking ; Duel; A Plenty; One Wheeler Will; Sir; Goodbye Ruth's; HairTrigger; Better Not To Know; Sunflower; Same Old Story; Option 8; Wait; Goodbye Ruths (slow).
Personnel: Ralph Alessi: trumpet; Drew Gress: double-bass; Jason Moran: piano (1-6, 8-11, 13-15); Andy Milne: piano (7, 12); Nasheet Waits: drums.