How we rate: our writers tend to review music they like within their preferred genres.
Chicago is best known for the electric blues style that arose there during the 1940s and continues to thrive today. Less celebrated is an earlier form of Chicago blues that originated in the 1920s. This acoustic style achieved great popularity during the Depression years when Southern blacks flocked to Chicago seeking jobs in the city’s factories, stockyards and slaughterhouses. (Chicago’s slaughterhouses have long been alluded to in blues songs. Think of how frequently you’ve heard the term "killing floor" in a blues context.)
Chicago In Mind is an entertaining collection of songs recorded between 1923 and 1949. Life in Chicago is the subject of many of these tunes, with some nifty piano instrumentals lending variety to the 23-track collection. While the CD provides an overview of early Chicago blues, it also documents the late-‘40s transition period when Muddy Waters, Little Walter, and a handful of other musicians pioneered the electric style of Chicago blues that’s since attracted millions of fans worldwide.
Some contemporary critics have panned early Chicago blues as light entertainment overly influenced by Vaudeville and too disengaged from the emotional lives of the people. It’s true these "race records" often coupled hokum lyrics with jazzy, syncopated melodies. Since this music was most often played at rent parties, the songs frequently dealt with drinking and carousing. But no one who listens to this CD can criticize the musicianship. Moreover, many of the songs truly did communicate the fears and joys of the city’s black populace.
Because many of Chicago’s early blues musicians were rural people who migrated to the big city, their music mixed the down-home with the citified. This dichotomy is evident in Papa Charlie Jackson’s "Maxwell Street Blues" (1925), the first nationally distributed blues 78 by a male singer. The song finds the dapper Jackson strumming a rural-sounding banjo while he pleads with the police to release his girlfriend, who’s been arrested for soliciting at the Sunday street market – a decidedly urban activity. On "Chicago Moan," the guitar great Tampa Red warns, "If you got a good woman/Here’s a lesson I give to you/Don’t carry her to Chicago/Men will take her ‘way from you."
Flamboyant piano players, including boogie-woogie masters Jimmy Blythe, Cow Cow Davenport and Albert Ammons, dominate the earliest songs in this collection. Recorded in 1937, Big Bill Broonzy’s "New Shake ‘Em on Down" foreshadows the modern Chicago blues and even features an electric guitarist. With drums, piano, and Muddy Waters on electric guitar, Little Johnny Jones’ "Big Town Playboy" (1949) presents the full-fledged combo style we recognize as modern Chicago blues. Ironically, this new style was rawer than its Chicago antecedents and thus more faithful to the blues’ Delta roots.
With wonderful performances by various guitarists, pianists, harp players and singers (Ida Cox, Sonny Boy Williamson, Washboard Sam, Sunnyland Slim, Big Maceo, Snooky Prior, Robert Jr. Lockwood, Robert Nighthawk and Little Walter), Chicago In Mind is an excellent sampler of pre-1950 Chicago blues.
Track Listing: Ida Cox - Chicago Bound Blues; Priscilla Stewart - Mecca Flats Blues; Jimmy Blythe