by Jack Bowers
John Coltranes compulsive search for newer and more meaningful forms of
musical expression continued almost to the moment of his death in 1967.
To Trane, rhythm and harmony, consonance and dissonance were fragments
of a greater spiritual quest, one in which music furnished a bridge over
which one might pass on his neverending journey toward inner peace and
happiness. Its not a goal that one ever reaches, but one that he
strives toward as long as there is breath in his body. Coltrane strived.
While he may not have completed his odyssey, his legacy lives on in the
openhearted convictions of those he influenced. In November1965
Coltrane recorded his expansive fivemovement suite, Meditations,
recreated here on its 30th anniversary by one of Tranes most ardent
disciples, David Liebman, and his ensemble before a live audience at New
Yorks Symphony Space. The 54minute work, played without interruption,
was transcribed by Caris Visentin who plays oboe in Liebmans group.
Its a turbulent, often inharmonious piece whose many moments of sound
and fury (as on Consequences, on which an extended twodrum
interchange leads to and underscores cacophonous passages by tenor,
guitar, trumpet and synthesizer) are counterbalanced by others of beauty
and repose (as, for example, in the final movement, Serenity). Nat
Hentoff, in his liner notes, says that David Baker, a professor of music
at the University of Indiana, once suggested to him that Tranes music
should be studied the way we now study the etudes of Bach and Brahms.
Perhaps so, as such densely structured works as Meditations, while
employing the traditional elements of Jazz, are more classical in
conception than those that are more emphatically improvised and
spontaneous. But that is for history to decide. Meanwhile, those who
value what Coltrane has contributed to the musics vocabulary may
content themselves with superior performances such as this one of his
prominent works.
Track Listing: Introduction; The Father and the Son and the Holy Ghost;
Compassion; Love; Consequences; Serenity (54:55)
Personnel: David Liebman, tenor saxophone; Vic Juris, guitar; Jamey
Haddad, drums, percussion; Phil Markowitz, piano, keyboards; Tony
Marino, bass. With special guests Billy Hart, drums; Cecil McBee, bass;
Tiger Okoshi, trumpet; Caris Visentin, oboe.