August 2001
Late Night
Archive
<& /articles/late_archive.tmp &>
|
Louis Armstrong's Public Image
By Marshall Bowden
Louis Armstrong has long occupied a difficult place in jazz history. Unquestionably
one of the music's leading architects, he presented, as his life and career advanced,
a public image that was increasingly at odds with the images of most jazz musicians
and often, with the times themselves. For this reason, his later work is usually
dismissed as not only inferior to his groundbreaking recordings with the Hot Fives
and Hot Sevens, but his very image is seen as a culturally inappropriate reminder
of the time not long ago in this nation's history when to be a black entertainer
meant presenting a palatable image to predominantly white audiences. There has
always been evidence that Armstrong felt strongly about the issue of racial inequality
in America in the form of some writing, conversations he had with various friends,
neighbors, and fellow musicians, and, most publicly, his comments on the Little
Rock school case. However, recent cataloging of over 600 reel-to-reel tapes in
the Louis Armstrong Archives has shown that privately he was much angrier about
racial injustice than he ever allowed his public to know.
Armstrong's musical talents have never been in question. His role in moving
jazz music from its contrapuntal ensemble roots in New Orleans to a music dominated
by talented solo performers is well documented. So is his considerable influence
on every generation of jazz trumpeters that succeeded him, from Dizzy Gillespie,
Miles Davis, and Freddie Hubbard to Wynton Marsalis and Nicholas Payton. Though
he was no longer breaking new ground by the end of the 1930s, his recordings
and live performances with the Louis Armstrong All-Stars gave audiences a chance
to hear the closest possible thing to the performances of legendary jazz groups
of the 1920s and before. The fact that Louis didn't play swing in the 30s nor
bop in the 40s did little to diminish his popularity or harm his career. Even
when jazz was no longer a vital force in the recording industry, Armstrong managed
to score a number one single with his rendition of "Hello Dolly",
displacing the Beatles from the top of the charts for that week. But this very
same popularity cost Armstrong much personal respect in the jazz community and
damaged his image with politically outspoken blacks in the 1950s and 1960. To
understand the divide that opened between he public and private Louis Armstrong,
as well as that between Armstrong and subsequent generations of jazz artists,
it is necessary to examine his background and the changes in jazz music and
American society that took place during his lengthy career.
Armstrong grew up in New Orleans' fabled Storyville section and lived, by all
accounts, in conditions of extreme poverty. His diet consisted primarily of
red beans, rice, okra, and the occasional scrap of meat. He often went barefoot,
owning few clothes. He saw, from an early age, prostitution, drunkenness, and
drug addiction. In addition, Louis' father was fairly non-existent in his life,
as he later wrote: "My father did not have time to teach me anything; he
was too busy chasing chippies." Even a cursory examination of Louis' life
and career show that he was hungry for acceptance and eager to please, and that
he searched for a mentor who could substitute for his absent father. He found
several in the course of his life, but none was as truly influential as Joe
"King" Oliver. Oliver took an interest in Armstrong and showed him
some of the basics of cornet technique. Oliver's main contribution to Louis'
development, though, was his interest in Louis both as a musician and as a person.
Oliver invited Louis to join his group in Chicago, thus launching one of the
most fruitful periods of Armstrong's career. When the opportunity to play in
Fletcher Henderson's band in New York opened up, Oliver released Louis to go
play with Henderson, never standing in his way.
A mentor who was less concerned with Louis' development as a musician was Joe
Glaser, who became Armstrong's manager in 1935. Glaser was concerned with getting
the most out of Louis, but he also got the trumpet star into films and appearances
with white stars like Bing Crosby. He steered Louis in more commercial directions,
choosing what was popular over what was artistic. He worked Armstrong hard,
perhaps to the detriment of the musician's health, but he also kept Armstrong's
career going through the demise of the big bands and the rise of bebop. Glaser
made lots of money off of Armstrong, but he helped Louis realize the full commercial
potential of the name he had painstakingly built for himself. Some feel that
Louis' steady journey into a career as a popular singer rather than a jazz musicians
was all Glaser's fault, but Louis knew that in order to keep his career going
he had to do what appealed to white audiences, and he knew that Glaser could
help him do just that. Armstrong often quoted the advice of a bouncer he knew
in New Orleans who told him, before he left to join Oliver in Chicago, "Always
keep a white man behind you that'll put his hand on you and say 'That's my nigger'".
At least in part because of his early experience of hunger and poverty, Armstrong
knew the value of his career. He was able to see what happened to other musicians
who had made the trip north from New Orleans. Jelly Roll Morton, jazz music's
first great composer, passed away in Los Angeles in 1941 in abject poverty,
victimized by his own music publisher. Joe Oliver died in Savannah in 1938,
earning a living as a pool hall janitor. Armstrong recognized that his career
was only as strong as his ability to deliver performances that people wanted
to hear. He viewed himself as an entertainer, just as other jazz musicians of
his era did. In the words of writer James Lincoln Collier:
"The image of the artist as being apart, a personage with special, almost
magical skills, descends to us from the Romantic period. It is hardly universal
to human culture. As recently as the eighteenth century, writers and painters
were dogs of the aristocracy, and actors and musicians classed with servants.
The Southern black lacked the idea of the artist almost entirely."
(The Making of Jazz: A Comprehensive History, Dell Publishing, 1978).
Lacking the idea of the artists, these early jazz performers did not readily
differentiate between high and low art influences in their music. Armstrong
played on riverboats, while Morton cut his teeth on vaudeville and minstrel
shows. As young musicians in New Orleans, both were exposed to a wide variety
of music, including marching bands, show tunes, ragtime, folk music, and even
opera. The influence of vaudeville provided the hokum heard on the introductions
to Morton's "Dead Man Blues" and "Sidewalk Blues", and the
erotic commentary of Armstrong's "Tight Like This".
It was precisely this tradition of the jazz musician as entertainer that the
bop musicians were reacting against. They refused to be relegated to the role
of entertainer, often behaving in temperamental or "difficult" ways,
refusing to discuss their music with non-musicians, and sometimes even turning
their backs on the audience. The entire attitude of bebop seemed to be "I
am playing for myself and for the other musicians who are playing with me. Your
listening is purely coincidental." They wanted to distance themselves from
what they saw as "Tomming" by the previous generation of jazz musicians.
They had developed that sense of themselves as artists that was lacking from
musicians who had grown up in the entertainment business. The 50s and 60s brought
about even more outspokenness by black musicians. Since jazz was no longer popular
music in any sense of the word, these musicians felt they had less to lose by
speaking out than did their forefathers. Also, blacks were speaking out in increasing
numbers, which decreased the risk to any one person who chose to speak out.
The increasingly vocal jazz community found it hard to understand why a musician
like Louis Armstrong, who was by far the most visible representative of jazz
music in the world, didn't speak out on the subjects of racism and discrimination.
The 1957 Little Rock school integration incident polarized the United States
on the subject of race. The Supreme Court had decreed that nine black students
were to be allowed to attend Central High School in Little Rock. On September
2, 1957, Arkansas governor Orval Faubus called in the National Guard, ostensibly
because he had heard that white supremacists were going to descend on the town.
He declared that Central was off limits to black students, and the town's black
high school was off limits to whites. More disturbing still was his statement
that "blood would run in the streets" if the black students attempted
to attend Central. He told a reporter that President Eisenhower was a hypocrite
and that he was sick to be a goodwill ambassador for a country that was in conflict
with its own people. There was a great deal of controversy, but Louis stood
by his statement. He also didn't make the trip to the Soviet Union that had
been planned for him as a "goodwill ambassador." Charles Mingus, one
of the new breed of jazz musicians who suffered mightily in his career because
he refused to bow to predominantly white audiences, record labels, and club
owners, commemorated the Little Rock event in his composition "Fables of
Faubus." But Armstrong's statements to the press stood out as a defining
moment in his life and career.
The Armstrong reel-to-reel tapes have been stored at Queens College in Flushing,
NY, a short trip from the home that Armstrong lived in with his fourth wife,
Lucille, from 1943 until his death in 1971. On them, he openly criticizes black
civil rights pioneers like Josephine Baker and Marcus Garvey, who he saw as
exploiters of America's racial problems for their own gain. He expresses the
belief that blacks simply had to endure the injustices regularly meted out to
them, though many personal stories he recounts demonstrate just how difficult
it could be to follow that advice, and he clearly harbored a great deal of rage
over the way black Americans were treated on a daily basis. Certainly it must
have been difficult to avoid answering his critics in a direct and satisfying
way for the sake of maintaining his broad, diverse fan base. "Showmanship
does not mean you're not serious," he merely said.
Armstrong would likely be honored to think that the occasion of the centennial
of his birth might make people think about race relations in America and that
a those who have criticized him in the past might take another look at his words
and actions on this subject. Fellow New Orleans native and trumpeter Nicholas
Payton has the last word on Armstrong: "The way Armstrong acted was part
of his genius, that he could bring such a high level of art into his performances,
yet do it in a way that would appeal to the common, ordinary person
Plus,
it's because of a Louis Armstrong that the doors of the music industry were
opened to later people who then could take on certain attitudes, like Miles
Davis."
|